Submitted by Anonymous on Sun, 09/27/1998 - 01:26 Forums: LML Archive From: Ed Armstrongby way of Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com> <ed [at] testelectronics.com> Subject: Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode Date: Sat, 26 Sep 1998 21:26:55 -0400 To: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Marv asks: 1. Which works better (diodes vs MOV) or are they about equal? 2. How do I know which one is right for the task at hand? 1. The Diodes work better for eliminating noise. However, the MOV's are safer, and handle higher current. The flyback spike voltage on the diode is around -0.7Volts. The MOV's spike voltage would be around -14 Volts, so you get more noise with the MOV. However, the MOV is safer because it will generally fail open and a diode fails shorted. If the diode fails, you won't be able to actuate the solenoid. 2. The coil of the solenoid tries to maintain a constant current going through it. When you de-energize the solenoid, the magnetic field around it collapses and generates a huge negative voltage. This voltage can be eliminated with the flyback diode or clipped with an MOV. Since the solenoid coil tries to maintain a constant current, the current going through the diode will be the same amount of current used to energize the solenoid. The voltage rating is the same as the voltage applied 12 Volts for a 12V system. For safety reasons you should at least double the voltages you expect. For small relays I recommend a 1N4001 rectifier diode. This diode is rated at 1Amp 50 Volts. Here are some Motorola part numbers 1N4001 50V 1A 1N5400 50V 3A MR750 50V 6A The MOV (Metal Oxide Varistor (look up Varistor when searching for it in a catalog)) is a non polarized device, and conducts if you exceed its voltage rating. You want to pick an MOV with a knee voltage slightly higher than what you expect to apply to the solenoid. I would pick 14 Volts for a 12V system. The amazing thing about MOV's is that they are very small for their current handling capabilities. Here are some Harris part numbers. Note that these are peak and not continuous duty currents. However, all you need for flyback is peak current. Part Volt Amps Size V18ZA05 14V 50A 5mm dia V18ZA1 14V 250A 7mm dia V18ZA2 14V 500A 10mm dia V18ZA3 14V 1000A 14mm dia V18ZA40 14V 2000A 20mm dia In my opinion there is no need to use anything higher than the first one, the V18ZA05. For the best of both worlds, you could put the MOV in parallel with the solenoid, and then put the diode in series. This would eliminate the -14V spike noise the MOV allowed and you would still be safe because if the diode failed short, all that would happen would be the noise would be allowed to get back on line. You would not loose the control of your solenoid. I think I will use this method on any larger solenoids that draw more than 2 amps. I am not this far along in my construction so I don't know if there are such large solenoids in my L360 Kit. All these parts are available at Newark Electronics 1-800-463-9275. Radio Shack also has these components. Radio Shack only resells these components, they do not manufacture them, so there is no quality issue here. Regards, Ed [I decided to forward this to The List as it contains lots of really interesting information that I thought others of you out there will find valuable... I hope you don't mind, Ed. There have been reports recently of flap and gear solenoids sticking (I assume with welded contacts) and it occurs to me that the motors which they are controlling are also inductive loads of sorts, are they not? If that's the case, then similar protection for the relay's contacts ought to be able to be afforded by components similar to these MOV's/diodes, as the relay contacts are nothing more than the switches which are controlling these motors, right? (The reason for the flyback control is to protect the switch, not the relay coil as stated long ago at the beginning of this thread...) So, the question is what can we do to protect those relay contacts to prevent arcing when we fire-up/shut-down those motors? Or is this thinking totally out of whack?? <M>] Post a Reply Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode Submitted by Anonymous on Sun, 09/27/1998 - 05:54 From: Tom McReynolds <tomcat [at] gigapixel.com> Sender: <tomcat [at] gigapixel.com> Subject: Re: Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode Date: Sat, 26 Sep 1998 22:54:33 -0700 To: Ed Armstrong (by way of Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com>) <ed [at] testelectronics.com> Cc: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Ed Armstrong (by way of Marvin Kaye ) wrote: > In my opinion there is no need to use anything higher than the first one, > the V18ZA05. For the best of both worlds, you could put the MOV in parallel > with the solenoid, and then put the diode in series. Will this work? Until the MOV conducts, the diode will be isolated from the flyback current. It seems to me that the diode won't have the opportunity to conduct at a lower voltage; it will only increase the flyback threshold voltage by adding a .7V drop to the MOV-diode series circuit. I would expect this to increase noise slightly. I think you either have to put the diode in parallel with the MOV, and hope the former doesn't fail (maybe the MOV will protect it somewhat from higher voltages), or give up on having the MOV. -Tom reply Post a Reply You must have JavaScript enabled to use this form. Your name Subject Comment * Switch to plain text editorMore information about text formats Text format Filtered HTMLPlain text Filtered HTMLWeb page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readable fashion or, if JavaScript is enabled, replaced with a spam resistent clickable link. Email addresses will get the default web form unless specified. If replacement text (a persons name) is required a webform is also required. Separate each part with the "|" pipe symbol. Replace spaces in names with "_".Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h1> <h2> <h3>Lines and paragraphs break automatically.Plain textNo HTML tags allowed.Each email address will be obfuscated in a human readable fashion or, if JavaScript is enabled, replaced with a spam resistent clickable link. Email addresses will get the default web form unless specified. If replacement text (a persons name) is required a webform is also required. Separate each part with the "|" pipe symbol. Replace spaces in names with "_".Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.Lines and paragraphs break automatically. Attachments Add a new file Files must be less than 512 MB.Allowed file types: jpg jpeg gif png txt doc docx xls xlsx pdf ppt pptx pps ppsx odt ods odp mp3 mov mp4 m4a m4v mpeg avi ogg oga ogv weba webp webm. Leave this field blank
Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode Submitted by Anonymous on Sun, 09/27/1998 - 05:54 From: Tom McReynolds <tomcat [at] gigapixel.com> Sender: <tomcat [at] gigapixel.com> Subject: Re: Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode Date: Sat, 26 Sep 1998 22:54:33 -0700 To: Ed Armstrong (by way of Marvin Kaye <marvkaye [at] olsusa.com>) <ed [at] testelectronics.com> Cc: <lancair.list [at] olsusa.com> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> << Lancair Builders' Mail List >> <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<--->>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >> Ed Armstrong (by way of Marvin Kaye ) wrote: > In my opinion there is no need to use anything higher than the first one, > the V18ZA05. For the best of both worlds, you could put the MOV in parallel > with the solenoid, and then put the diode in series. Will this work? Until the MOV conducts, the diode will be isolated from the flyback current. It seems to me that the diode won't have the opportunity to conduct at a lower voltage; it will only increase the flyback threshold voltage by adding a .7V drop to the MOV-diode series circuit. I would expect this to increase noise slightly. I think you either have to put the diode in parallel with the MOV, and hope the former doesn't fail (maybe the MOV will protect it somewhat from higher voltages), or give up on having the MOV. -Tom reply
Solenoid flyback MOV vs diode
Submitted by Anonymous on
Post a Reply